The Current

Whatever Russia did, CIA has its own history of meddling in elections

As the CIA cries foul over Russian election interference, more than a few observers find it a little bit rich given the CIA's past meddling in elections abroad. The Current speaks to a history professor who says, "History is replete with ironies."
The CIA is outraged about U.S. election interference by hackers from Russia. But some observers think that's hypocritical given the CIA's own history meddling in elections in other countries. (Larry Downing/Reuters)

Read story transcript

News that the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency believes that Russian hackers meddled in the recent American presidential election has dominated the news agenda this week. 

On Dec. 15, the Obama Administration suggested that Russian President Vladimir Putin had personally authorised the hacking of the Democrats' emails, something the Russian leader denies.

"It certainly would be unprecedented in terms of a power, such as Russia, a great power, intervening directly in the elections of the United States," says Richard Immerman, a history professor at Temple University and the author of several books about the CIA. 

"The CIA is a very professional agency," Immerman tells The Current's Friday host  Piya Chattopadhyay.

"I have no reason to suspect that the CIA assessment is anything other than an honest assessment on the part of the CIA," he says.

Since the end of the Cold War, it's been harder to gauge what the CIA has been up, says Richard Immerman, because internal documents have yet to be declassified. (Kirill Kudryavtsev/AFP/Getty Images)

Immerman believes the CIA is not being politicised because of the election of president-elect Trump. 

So is the CIA hypocritical in its accusations?

Immerman says that since it's creation the CIA has a long history of influencing foreign elections. 

"The CIA was established in 1947 and received its authority to engage in covert action 1948."

He adds that in 1948, the CIA became involved in attempting to influence the election in Italy.

So while Immerman believes one can't excuse Russia's behaviour, the U.S. once worked the same way.

"History shouldn't work that way," he says.

"There is an irony, but history is replete with ironies."

Listen to the full conversation at the top of this post.

This segment was produced by The Current's John Chipman.