Coming to grips: Sticky stuff ban provokes managers, players

Kansas City manager Mike Matheny warned opponents that if they act like Philadelphia's Joe Girardi and ask umpires to check Royals pitchers for sticky substances, it would provoke his team.

New York Yankees reliever Zack Britton and Max Scherzer, members of the players' association's executive committee, called on Major League Baseball to end on-field checks by umpires and replace them with monitors who would conduct inspections in clubhouses, dugouts and bullpens.

"If I'm a young kid at the game and I'm asking my dad, `Well, hey, what's going on? Why they getting checked? What he's going to say? `Well, they think everyone's cheating," Britton said Wednesday. "I mean, is that what we want the game to be about, like we're assuming you're cheating? I just think it's a bad look."

On-field exams of pitchers started Monday, a week after baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred announced a crackdown on unauthorized grip substances. When umpire Alfonso Marquez approached Scherzer for a third time during Tuesday's game, as requested by Girardi, the three-time Cy Young Award winner tossed his glove and hat to the ground, unbuckled his belt and appeared ready to take off his pants.

"I will say this: If somebody goes hunting for something on one of our guys, I'll guarantee we're going to have every guy on that bench and every other eye we can get on what might be happening. But that's not a road I want to go down," Matheny said Wednesday at Yankee Stadium. "Let's let the umpires do what they're told to do."

When Oakland reliever Sergio Romo was checked by the umpires after pitching the seventh inning on Tuesday night, the veteran right-hander flung his belt onto the turf and dropped his trousers.

'Bad for baseball'

Britton said while the goal of eliminating sticky substances was laudable, the method of enforcement was hurtful.

"I just think the optics of it are so bad for baseball," he said during batting practice, speaking in front of the Yankees dugout. "Having players checked on the field — we're talking about that, we're not talking about Wander Franco's debut, we're not talking about how well Gerrit [Cole] threw and how well Max Scherzer threw and all this other stuff around the game. We're talking about guys getting checked on the field, guys dropping their pants on the field, guys throwing their belts off.

Cole also serves on the executive subcommittee, which along with the union staff supervises collective bargaining to replace the labor contract that expires on Dec. 1.

Britton said there have not been talks between the union and MLB in several weeks on foreign substances.

Nationals GM criticizes Phillies' Girardi

Nationals general manager Mike Rizzo criticized Girardi during an interview on Washington's 106.7 The Fan. The Phillies manager said he became suspicious because Scherzer was touching his hair more than usual on the mound.

Scherzer said he did that because he couldn't grip the ball and needed moisture on his fingers. He also said he got tired of tasting rosin.

"It's embarrassing for Girardi. It's embarrassing for the Phillies. It's embarrassing for baseball," Rizzo said. "Yes, he was playing games. And hey that's his right. Gamesmanship. Had nothing to do with substances. He had no probable cause to ask for it. The umps shouldn't have allowed it. ... He's a con artist. ... He has been doing that for years on TV."

Britton said he understood Scherzer's reaction.

"To check Scherzer, I thought was a little over the top. I mean, he's pretty smart," Britton said. "He's not going to be doing anything. But it's part of what the game may look like from here on out where managers would check pitchers."

'It's going to be awkward'

Matheny predicted more tension ahead.

"There's people who rightfully will be very offended by being — I don't if it's being a called a cheater or insinuating — but there's going to be a lot of this, I mean it's going to be awkward," he said. And you could see yesterday, a guy comes off the field after giving up some runs and if you get squeezed a little bit behind the plate, I mean it's going to turn into some stuff."

Mets ace Jacob deGrom was the first pitcher checked under the new policy — he pitched the opener of a doubleheader Monday against Atlanta at Citi Field and calmly went through the protocol.

"The best on the planet, he had no problem with it. You saw deGrom," Boston manager Alex Cora said. "Obviously Max, that was a different situation. Something that we have the green light to do and obviously they took exception and he got upset."

Britton said the checks would unnecessarily increase tension between players and umpires. He faulted Manfred for not speaking with media on the matter. Manfred did not hold a news conference after the June 3 owners' meeting when MLB first said a crackdown would be upcoming.

"It's just players speaking out about it. I would love to hear someone from MLB answer questions from the media, like we do every day," Britton said. "I would like to hear from Manfred. He's the commissioner of the game. I'd love to hear Manfred answer the questions and not his players."

"So, yeah, I think it's frustrating for the players that we haven't heard anything from him yet," he said.

Britton said Statcast metrics could be used for probable cause for enhanced checks based on pitchers' revolutions per minute.

"Nowadays you can kind of find out where a guy's average spin rate would be and if it's jumping," he said. "Just use common sense, right?"