Business·Marketplace

14-year-old girl forced off flight; Abuse allegations in long-term care home: CBC's Marketplace cheat sheet

CBC's Marketplace rounds up the consumer and health news you need from the week.

Consumer and health news you need from the week

A mother and her daughter are pictured similing in their living room.
Catherine and Camryn Larkan are pictured here. (Submitted by Catherine Larkan)

Miss something this week? Don't panic. CBC's Marketplace rounds up the consumer and health news you need.

Want this in your inbox? Get the Marketplace newsletter every Friday.

Parents outraged after girl, 14, forced off Porter Airlines flight

Parents outraged after unaccompanied teen bumped from Porter flight

3 months ago
Duration 2:12
The family of a 14-year-old who was travelling alone and was forced to leave a Porter Airlines flight in Toronto due to a weight imbalance says it shouldn’t have happened even though they didn’t pay an extra fee to guarantee her seat or have her accompanied by airline staff.

The parents of a 14-year-old girl say they're outraged after their daughter was removed from a Porter Airlines flight last month and left to her own devices for 24 hours — without compensation or supervision from airline staff. 

Camryn Larkan was flying alone for only the second time on Aug. 30, headed home to Victoria, B.C., after visiting a friend and family in Toronto.

She boarded the plane and was sitting in her seat ready for takeoff when a flight attendant told her there was a problem, and that she needed to grab her bags and get off the aircraft.

She said she was "really confused."

"I thought I was coming back to my seat. I thought that they were just going to take my bags," Camryn said. "As soon as I got off the plane and I saw that the door had closed, that's when I started to, like, get really anxious."

Camryn said she later learned the plane took off without her and some other passengers due to a weight imbalance. She was rebooked on a flight to Victoria at the same time the next day, and the airline sent her on her way. Her dad, who had brought her to the airport in Toronto, rushed back to pick her up.

"I'm just glad that my dad was there, because if he wasn't I would have been alone," Camryn said. 

Camryn's parents say they're angry that a minor travelling alone was forced to deplane with little information or support from the airline.

"They put my child in imminent danger," said Catherine Larkan, her mom. "It was completely negligent and it shouldn't happen to any other minor."

A spokesperson for Porter Airlines told CBC News the 14-year-old was removed from the plane due to a "weight and balance issue," but that its staff wasn't aware she was under the age of 18. Read more

Family alleges neglect after 95-year-old's stay at Quebec care home

A framed photo of an elderly woman wearing a tiara
Just months after Aline Besner moved into her son's family home, she had to be hospitalized and then transferred to Villa des Brises in Gatineau, Que. Days before she died, doctors found 'profound bedsores' on her back. (Rachel Watts/CBC)

Guy Maisonneuve held back tears the day he dropped his 95-year-old mother, Aline Besner, off at a Gatineau, Que., care home on Feb. 26.

Her room on the second floor of Villa des Brises smelled like urine, staff wouldn't make eye contact and no one would help transfer Besner into bed, he says.

Located in a private facility managed by Mandala Santé, the floor is partly run by the regional health authority, the Centre intégré de santé et des services sociaux de l'Outaouais (CISSSO).

The floor is designed as a temporary residence for post-acute care and a place for those who may need rehabilitation before returning home or being transferred to a long-term placement.

"From the moment I stepped into the villa, I was filled with dread, absolute dread," said Maisonneuve, sitting at his kitchen table, steps from the room where he hoped his mother would spend her final days, at home.

But after being diagnosed with advanced dementia at the Wakefield hospital, Besner moved into the Villa des Brises transitional unit while waiting for a permanent placement at a long-term care facility.

A bad first impression soon turned into major concern for Besner's safety when Maisonneuve was told by a neighbouring resident his mom was having falls, didn't have access to drinking water, wasn't being bathed regularly and that her emergency call button would either be out of reach or go unanswered for hours.

On April 14, Besner died in a hospital bed, surrounded by her family. Quebec's coroner's office is investigating her death.

More families and former residents are coming forward, some claiming abuse and "incompetence" on the transitional floor.

The care home would not comment on specific events. Mandala Santé and the regional health authority both declined repeated requests for an interview. Read more

  • Marketplace has uncovered abuse in long-term care homes before. You can watch those episodes anytime on YouTube or CBC Gem.

Why some Canadian insurance companies are bringing in a wildfire tactical team

A white truck owned by Wildfire Defense Systems is emblazoned with the company's logo and is marked as "non-emergency."
Montana-based Wildfire Defense Systems dispatches field staff to 22 U.S. states along with Alberta and British Columbia to do last-minute fire prevention work around insured properties. (Submitted by Scott Eskwitt)

When Joelle Fraser-McGaghey had to evacuate her home during the 2016 Fort McMurray wildfire, she only had a few minutes to pack before her family had to get out the door.

Trying to pull outdoor furniture away from her house was not at the top of her list.

"Honestly, I'm not thinking, 'should I remove that propane tank?' I'm thinking, 'let's get my kids out of here and let's get us to safety,'" she said in an interview.

Insurance companies have realized homeowners aren't necessarily aware of last-minute fire prevention when they're packing up to evacuate. So a growing number are paying a U.S.-based firm to take on that responsibility.

Fraser-McGaghey's insurance provider, Economical, is one of several Canadian insurers — including Aviva, Intact and Gore Mutual — that have hired Montana-based Wildfire Defense Systems to provide "loss intervention services."

The company sends field staff into communities when a wildfire is looming to move patio furniture away from walls, clean out gutters, set up sprinklers and otherwise try to keep homes from catching fire. 

"I thought, any way to prevent someone else losing their home — why not?" said Fraser-McGaghey.

The company is active across 22 U.S. states, but started working on behalf of insurers in B.C. and Alberta for the first time this year. Read more


What else is going on?

Canada is getting poorer when compared to its wealthy peers, data shows

Tepid economic growth, combined with a population boom, has hit Canada's standing among rich countries

Man who received world's 1st eye and face transplant says it changed his life

Aaron James can't see out of his new eye. But the fact that his body accepted the transplant is a milestone

Major public service union asks members not to shop in downtown Ottawa

PSAC promotes and then clarifies purpose of 'buy nothing' campaign


Marketplace needs your help!

A graphic of a health care worker holding a stethescope, with the words "Primary care concerns?" written on it.
(David Abrahams/CBC News)

We want to hear about your experience with family doctors! Are you having trouble finding one and turning to virtual or private care? Or maybe you're having trouble getting access to one you already have and have felt forced to turn to walk-ins or the emergency room. Write to us, marketplace@cbc.ca.

Green graphic that reads mind your business and has images of dollar signs, quote bubbles and stock graphs.

Are you looking for the latest in business news? You'll want to subscribe to this newsletter, too.

Mind Your Business is your weekly look at what's happening in the worlds of economics, business and finance. Subscribe now.

Catch up on past episodes of Marketplace on CBC Gem.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Dexter McMillan

Associate Producer, Marketplace

Dexter McMillan is an investigative journalist with CBC Marketplace based in Toronto who specializes in telling stories about data. Previously, he was with the investigative unit and digital graphics. Got a tip? Email him at dexter.mcmillan@cbc.ca

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Subscribe to our newsletter for consumer news, tips and insider info to help you save cash and stay healthy.

...

The next issue of The Marketplace Watchdog newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in the Subscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.