British Columbia

Commercial Drive 12-storey tower in question after Vancouver releases community plan

The draft community plan for the Vancouver neighbourhood of Grandview-Woodland calls for a maximum tower height of nine storeys to maintain the 'vibe of The Drive.'

To keep the 'vibe of The Drive' city plan has a maximum tower height of 9 storeys and lower density

An artist's rendering of the 12-storey project as proposed by the Kettle Society and Boffo Development for the corner of Commercial Drive and Venables St., seen looking south. (Boffo Properties)

The future of a controversial tower proposed for Vancouver's Commercial Drive is now in question, with the release of the city's draft neighbourhood plan that says a 12-storey high-rise doesn't fit "the vibe of The Drive."

The Kettle Boffo project, which has drawn lawn signs and protests as well as supporters, is proposed for the corner of Commercial Drive and Venables St. by developer Boffo Properties and the Kettle Society, which offers social services on the site now.

The project would include up to 30 units of supportive housing, about 200 units of market housing and social services offered by Kettle in an expanded facility.

The current view from the intersection where Venables St. crosses Commercial Drive. The property on the left, which houses the Kettle Friendship Society, is the one planned for redevelopment. Further north on Commercial Drive, there is already an apartment tower of more than 10 storeys. (Google Streetview)

Looming tower?

The developer has 12 storeys planned, with five storeys along the street.

But the city's newly-released draft plan for the Grandview-Woodland neighbourhood calls for just six to nine storeys on the property, with a limit of four storeys on the Drive itself.

"This proposal did kind of loom over Commercial Drive" in the view of those opposed, said Kent Munro, assistant director of planning for the city.

"We've set parameters to say, no ... we're protecting the four storey or lower limit of Commercial Drive to keep the vibe of the Drive." 

The community plan also calls for lower density on the site.

The room was hot, as were some tempers, as Grandview-Woodland residents met in July 2013 to discuss the city's plans for increasing their neighbourhood's density. (CBC)

Developer 'disappointed'

The developer from Boffo Properties said he's glad the long-awaited community plan is out, but the height and density restrictions would make the project unsustainable.

"We are a little disappointed with the draft plan's recommendations but we remain optimistic that there is still flexibility at our location," said Daniel Boffo.

The proposal offers supportive housing, expanded social services and other amenities without a taxpayer cost — paid for by the market housing units, said Boffo.

Going to six and nine stories would leave a funding gap, which the city acknowledged in its report.

"I'm not clear as to ... how that would be filled," said Boffo.

The Kettle Society, Boffo Properties and the city each own parcels of the land that would be developed.

The draft Grandview-Woodland Community Plan shows some possible configurations of a tower at Commercial Drive and Venables St. (City of Vancouver)

Tall tower still possible

The draft community plan doesn't rule out the possibility of a taller tower, however.

It sets principles and parameters that a future application would have to meet in the neighbourhood, but the city is indicating there may be flexibility, depending on the community amenities offered.

More social services or supportive housing could tip those scales, Munro said.

"There could be opportunities to massage what's in the community plan to achieve those goals," he said.

"The Kettle is an incredibly valued and important social service in the community. The city wants to do everything it can to support it."

Boffo and the Kettle's executive director both said they plan to ask supporters of the project to speak up when city council considers the draft plan, which may be later this summer.

The property in question, at the corner of Commercial Drive and Venables Street, currently has a low-rise building and a parking lot. (Google Street View)