Parents guilty of 'spanking' daughter granted conditional discharge
B.C. couple assaulted 14-year-old with mini hockey stick and skipping rope after finding nude photos
A judge in Salmon Arm, B.C., has sentenced a couple who were convicted of assault for spanking their 14-year-old daughter to a conditional discharge with no jail time or criminal record.
The father and mother — both from Salmon Arm — were found guilty in January for hitting their daughter with a mini hockey stick and skipping rope after learning she had sent nude photos of herself to her boyfriend on Snapchat.
Provincial court Judge Edmond de Walle said the parents were genuinely remorseful for the incident and have completed counselling since then. He added the couple is not a risk to the community, has no criminal record and is highly regarded in Salmon Arm.
- Read Provincial Court judgement
- Parents guilty of assaulting daughter over nude Snapchat photos to be sentenced Tuesday
- 'Spanking' over nude Snapchat photo leads to assault conviction for parents
However, the judge also said the parents should have accepted responsibility for their actions and pleaded guilty. The Crown had earlier argued the parents didn't do so because they only felt remorse when they realized what they had done was against the law.
The couple's lawyer argued the trial has been hard on the family, and the teenage daughter felt it difficult to go out in public because of the attention it received.
The defence also argued the parents are volunteers with a local school and in the community and a criminal record would impact their ability to continue their service.
Bruises reported to school
The incident took place on Valentine's Day of last year, and only came to light after the girl showed her bruised buttocks to two of her girlfriends, who in turn reported what they had seen to their school principal.
De Walle found no excuse for the spanking. in his judgment, he said although any parent would be concerned about a teenager sending nude photos of herself, responding to these acts by spanking her with an object "is simply not believable or acceptable by any measure of current social consensus."
According to the decision, the father struck his daughter two or three times with a plastic mini hockey stick about 45 centimetres in length.
When he told his wife what had happened, the decision says, she picked up a skipping rope and hit her daughter two or three times on the buttocks.
The parents argued they had disciplined their daughter this way out of compassion and love.