British Columbia

Vancouver Hootsuite deal sparks conflict rule concerns

Democracy Watch founder Duff Conacher maintains the the Vancouver Charter has two contradictory sections on conflict of interest which need to be changed.

Civic watchdog calls for rewrite of Vancouver's conflict rules

Mayor sued over Hootsuite deal

11 years ago
Duration 2:24
Civil suit against Mayor Gregor Robertson is unlikely to succeed

Democracy Watch founder Duff Conacher says the the Vancouver Charter has two contradictory sections on conflict of interest which need to be clarified.

The focus on the city's conflict of interest rules comes after rival mayoral candidate Glen Chernen filed a petition in B.C. Supreme Court on Friday, alleging Robertson was in a conflict of interest for participating in discussions surrounding the lease of a city owned building to the social media company Hootsuite.

Conacher says the lawsuit likely won't succeed because the city's conflict of interest rules are far from clear.

"B.C. is not only the wild west, but the widely undemocratic and unethical west when it comes to donations, lobbying, elections and dealing with ethical issues properly," he said.

In the petition, Chernen says Hootsuite provided substantial campaign and political assistance to Robertson when he ran for his second mayoral term in 2012.

He says the city owned property at 5 East 8th Avenue subsequently leased  to Hootsuite ,  was not re-tendered for lease under a transparent process.

City manager says no conflict

However, Vancouver city manager Penny Ballem says nothing could be further from the truth.

"I can absolutely assure you that there is no involvement of council or any member of council in any negotiations around our real estate transactions including this case."

Vancouver city manager Penny Ballem says there is no political interference in real estate transactions at Vancouver City Hall. (CBC)

Hootsuite and Robertson have both denied any wrong doing.  Robertson calls the allegations bizarre and Hootsuite says it paid fair market value for its lease.

The city has 21 days to officially respond to the allegations and the public has its first issue to ponder in the run up to the civic elections in November.