Canada

'High degree of confidence' Israel didn't strike hospital in Gaza, says Canada's defence minister

Ottawa has a "high degree of confidence" that Israel did not strike the al-Ahli Hospital in Gaza City on Tuesday after an independent review by the Canadian military, Defence Minister Bill Blair said in a statement late Saturday evening.

Review found 'errant rocket' fired from Gaza Strip caused deadly blast at al-Ahli Hospital

Pedestrians walk through an explosion site strewn with destroyed vehicles.
An independent review conducted by the Canadian military determined a rocket fired from inside the Gaza Strip was responsible for a deadly strike at the al-Ahli Hospital in Gaza City on Oct. 17. (Abed Khaled/The Associated Press)

Ottawa has a "high degree of confidence" that Israel did not strike the al-Ahli Hospital in Gaza City on Tuesday after an independent review by the Canadian military, Defence Minister Bill Blair said in a statement late Saturday evening.

Canada believes the more likely scenario is that the strike was caused by an "errant rocket" fired from the Gaza Strip, Blair's statement said.

Palestinian officials said 471 people were killed in the hospital blast. An Israeli official said it appeared to be "several dozen." A U.S. intelligence report estimated the number of those killed to be "probably at the low end of the 100 to 300 spectrum."

The pronouncement from Ottawa came days after the U.S. said its own review found that Israel was not responsible for the hospital blast.

U.S. President Joe Biden said during a visit to Israel on Wednesday that he was confident the "other team" bore responsibility.

On Thursday, facing pressure to provide Canada's position on the matter, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said his government was taking "all necessary steps" to form its own understanding of what happened.

The Canadian Forces Intelligence Command conducted its own "review and analysis" at the prime minister's request, Blair's statement said.

A statement from the Department of National Defence on Saturday evening said that the analysis was based on open source and classified reporting.

"This assessment is informed by an analysis of the blast damage to the hospital complex, including adjacent buildings and the area surrounding the hospital, as well as the flight pattern of the incoming munition," the statement read.

Reporting from Canada's allies corroborates the findings, the Defence Department added. Besides the U.S., France also said earlier this week the hospital blast was not the result of an Israeli military strike. 

Blair promised the government would "continue to provide updates as new information becomes available," and reiterated Canada's "sincere condolences" to all who lost loved ones in the explosion.

WATCH | Expert explains what evidence could determine cause of hospital blast:

What experts would look for to determine cause of Gaza hospital blast

1 year ago
Duration 4:09
Andres Gannon, an assistant professor of political science at Vanderbilt University, discusses what evidence experts would use to determine what caused a deadly explosion at a Gaza City hospital. He warns that the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas would make it more difficult to identify the cause.

Hamas pointed blame at Israel

In the wake of the blast on Oct. 17, Hamas had quickly blamed an Israeli military airstrike for the carnage. Israel subsequently released images that it said proved it was caused by a misfire from Gaza.

Israel's ambassador to Canada, Iddo Moed, issued a statement Sunday welcoming the Canadian review and said this is a war "where our enemies weaponize media to fuel hatred both in the Middle East and around the world."

A senior French military official told The Associated Press on Friday that its own review of the intelligence also found Israel was not responsible, while the United Nations called for an independent investigation.

The latest conflict had begun 10 days earlier when Hamas militants crossed the border into Israel and conducted a series of brazen attacks on civilians.

Israel retaliated, raining airstrikes down on the Gaza Strip and putting the territory under siege. Its military is said to be preparing for a ground assault.

The Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry says more than 4,300 people have been killed in Gaza in total. More than 1,400 in Israel have been killed, most of them slain in the surprise Oct. 7 attacks, according to the Israeli government.

The Canadian government has deemed Hamas a terrorist entity since 2002.

A young girl wearing a pink shirt and pink backpack carries her belongings past the ruins of a community hospital.
A girl carrying her belongings walks on in the area of Al-Ahli hospital, where hundreds of people were killed on Oct. 17. (Mohammed Al-Masri/Reuters)

Canadian aid for Gaza

Earlier on Saturday, the Canadian government announced it would provide an additional $50 million for humanitarian assistance in the Gaza Strip as the region's border crossing with Egypt opened to let in a trickle of desperately needed aid.

International Development Minister Ahmed Hussen issued a statement from Cairo, Egypt, saying the federal government will ensure none of the money goes to Hamas.

Hussen said the money will be used to provide the Palestinian population with food, water, medical assistance, protection services and other life-saving aid.

"The critical and immediate needs of civilians affected by the crisis become clearer with each day that goes by," Hussen's statement said.

"As Canada's partners make their growing needs known, this new assistance will allow us to provide them funding quickly so they can scale up their efforts to help people in urgent need."

The pledge, on top of $10 million Canada already committed, is expected to be sent to humanitarian organizations already in the war-ravaged area.

On Saturday, Hussen was attending a peace summit in Cairo with Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly.

The ministers issued a joint statement saying they planned to reiterate Canada's condemnation of the Hamas attacks on Israel while also highlighting Canada's concerns over the deteriorating humanitarian situation in Gaza, which is home to 2.3 million people.

Just 20 trucks carrying humanitarian aid were allowed to enter Gaza from Egypt on Saturday. Aid agencies say their loads won't be enough to address the needs of the population, which is now rationing food and drinking dirty water. A second convoy of more than a dozen aid trucks were headed to Gaza on Sunday.

More than 200 trucks carrying aid have been waiting at the border for days.

About half of Gaza's residents have fled their homes. Hospitals are running low on medical supplies and fuel for generators amid widespread blackouts exacerbated by waves of Israeli airstrikes. Meanwhile, Palestinian militants continue to fire rockets into Israel.

WATCH | Steps CBC News takes to verify photos, videos from Israel and Gaza: 

What goes into verifying videos from the Israel-Hamas war

1 year ago
Duration 7:59
The National’s Adrienne Arsenault breaks down the steps CBC News takes to verify photos and videos that come out of Gaza and Israel during the war.

With files from CBC News and Reuters