Manitoba

Winnipeg 'phans' come together to celebrate cult film that captivated city 50 years ago

Die-hard "phans" took over the Burton Cummings Theatre this weekend to once again watch the 1970s cult film that's kept Winnipeggers enthralled for half a century.

'Everybody knows all the words to everything'

A woman holding a folder as well as a newspaper clip
Mary-Ann Vaillancourt remembers coming to the now-defunct Garrick Theatre to watch the 1974 movie Phantom of the Paradise 50 years ago in Winnipeg. Hundreds of fans of the cult classic were in the city's downtown this weekend for an event celebrating the film's 50th anniversary. (Natalia Weichsel/Radio-Canada)

Die-hard "phans" took over the Burton Cummings Theatre this weekend to once again watch the 1970s cult film that's kept Winnipeggers enthralled for half a century.

Brian De Palma's 1974 rock opera Phantom of the Paradise may not have been an international box office hit when it came out 50 years ago, but in Winnipeg, it hasn't been forgotten.

The comedy-horror, glam-rock-fueled mash-up of The Phantom of the Opera and Goethe's Faust was a smash hit in the city, developing a cult following that's continued to grow over the years.

Mary-Ann Vaillancourt was 10 years old when the film premiered. She remembers coming to the now-defunct Garrick Theatre with friends to watch it.

"I stayed for two shows," she said.  "And I did it again the next weekend. And I did it every weekend that I was allowed to come out."

Vaillancourt was one of the hundreds of people who showed up for the latest "Phantompalooza," a local event that, this year, marked the film's 50th anniversary.

Craig Wallace, a member of the Phantom 50th committee, said the two planned screenings of a restored version of the film sold out in a day and a half. A matinee, also featuring a Q&A with cast members, was added to meet the demand.

A film poster on a wall that says 'Phantom of the Paradise 50th anniversary Nov. 2nd 2024.'
Two planned screenings of the film sold out in a day and a half, organizers say. (Natalia Weichsel/Radio-Canada)

"Winnipeg has brought a lot of people from other provinces here, and they see what we see," said Dean Hunter, singer with Phantom tribute band Swanage, who's also on the committee.

"They might be from all over the world, but they love this movie as much as we do. And we just like to share it with them."

Listen | 'Phantom' superfan on the film's staying power
Brian De Palma's film Phantom of the Paradise first released in 1974. The film flopped almost everywhere except Winnipeg. Next year marks the film's 50th anniversarry. A team of Swan superfans has planned a special celebration.... that's ALREADY sold out! Gloria Dignazio is founder of the Phantompalooza and explains the film's popularity with Guest Host Shannah-Lee Vidal.

'Everybody knows all the words to everything'

The celebration brought back a lot of memories for fans who attended the matinee Saturday.

Betty Moroz, from Garson, Man., was 14 when she first watched it.

Crowds sitting on the balconies of a theatre
The celebration brought back a lot of memories for fans who attended the matinee Saturday. (Natalia Weichsel/Radio-Canada)
Listen | Kevin Smith on 'Phantom of the Paradise'
Guest host Emily Brass spoke with American actor Kevin Smith who is coming to Winnipeg to share his love for the cult classic film, Phantom of the Paradise.

"I thought it was kind of freaky back then," she said, but it stuck with her.

"It's very powerful, very moving. The music, the love and, what you would do for love. Anything for love."

"I have two copies at home," said Stephanie Starr, who came to the screening with her family.

"We love it. We've seen the movies many times before. And of course, you got to get the merchandise, right? I got a couple of buttons."

A man wearing a black leather suit and a silver mask that covers half his face plays a keyboard, surrounded by synthesizers and other musical equipment.
William Finley in 'Phantom of the Paradise.' The comedy-horror rock opera was a smash hit in Winnipeg, even if it flopped elsewhere (20th Century Fox)

For other Winnipeggers like Tom Glenewinkel, the matinee was the first time they've actually seen the film.

"Everybody knows all the words to everything," Glenewinkel said. "It was just a great movie to watch, and just to be part of the experience of everybody enjoying it and getting into it."

Vaillancourt brought a CD of the movie's soundtrack to the matinee and newspaper clippings about the film she kept with her over the years.

She hoped to meet Paul Williams — the film's co-star and composer of its songs — who decades ago replied to her fan letter.

"'Dear Mary-Ann, thank you for your letter telling me how much you enjoyed Phantom.… P.S. I think I've only seen the movie about four times myself,'" Vaillancourt read, saying that at that point she'd seen the film about 10 times already.

A newspaper clipping showing an article with the headline "'Phantom' and its star are double phenomena," held by a woman who is looking at it.
Mary-Ann Vaillancourt brought to the matinee the movie's soundtrack, and newspaper clippings about the film she kept with her over the years. (Natalia Weichsel/Radio-Canada)

"He made my whole day and my whole summer," she added. "The music is still phenomenal now, and I still listen to it if I want to just be able to sing along, every single word."

With files from Radio-Canada's Natalia Weichsel