Montreal

'They are trying to empty my pockets': Quebec drivers stunned by dramatic increase in parking fines

Quebec drivers have been getting quite a shock in recent weeks to learn that parking tickets now carry fines as high as $200 in some Quebec municipalities.

Sébastien St-François parked on street outside his office in Vieux-Longueuil and got ticket for $169

Sébastien St-François says he thinks a parking ticket of $169 is an 'abusive' fine. (CBC)

Quebec drivers have been getting quite a shock in recent weeks to learn that parking tickets now carry fines as high as $200 in some Quebec municipalities. 

"This is crazy," said Sébastien St-François, a Longueuil business owner who was slapped with a fine for $169.

St-François parked on Chambly Road in Vieux-Longueuil, right in front of his office, because construction work was blocking access to his regular parking lot.

"I have a parking space in the back for which I pay every month, but because of all this, I could not access my parking space that morning."

Parking on one side of the street is forbidden before 7:30 a.m. He got the ticket at 7:17 a.m.

"I'm not only frustrated because they're preventing me from accessing my parking spot, which gave rise to the parking ticket in the first place, but now I get the feeling that they are trying to empty my pockets," St-François told CBC News. He said he will be contesting the ticket in court.

Another Longueuil resident, Caroline Lacoste, said she "almost had a heart attack" when she saw the $169 fine on the ticket she'd been issued. Her car was parked on the wrong side of a street in Longueuil, an offence that used to cost $43. 

Lacoste, who lives in Longueuil, brought her complaint to city council last week. 

"I find this abusive," she told council.

Changes to Highway Safety Code

Coun. Éric Beaulieu, the vice-chair of Longueuil's executive committee, blamed an amendment to Quebec's Highway Safety Code, passed last May.

"The city is deferring to the fee set by the Quebec government," Beaulieu told Radio-Canada. 

Parking tickets now cost $169 in some Quebec municipalities because of a change made without warning in provincial legislation.
Parking tickets now cost $169 in some Quebec municipalities because of a change made without warning in provincial legislation. (Thomas Gerbet/Radio-Canada)

The law says a vehicle cannot be stopped "in a place where parking is prohibited by a sign." In the spring, the fine for doing so was increased to between $100 and $200, up from $30 to $60.

The new fine is higher than the $90 ticket you'd get for driving more than 25-to-29 km/h above the limit. 

It's about the same as the fine levied for failing to stop at a stop sign or a red light.

Province didn't advertise change

Caroline Lacoste received a $169 ticket for parking on the wrong side of a Longueuil street in July. (Thomas Gerbet/Radio-Canada)

However, the provincial Transport Ministry did not warn road users, and the change is nowhere to be found in the list of safety code amendments the ministry published online.

Cities that have their own parking legislation appear not to have adopted the change.

In Sherbrooke, a parking ticket will still cost you $33; in Quebec City, it's $43, and in Gatineau, it's $53. Montreal's parking infraction rate recently went up to $60.

Trois-Rivières, Longueuil and Mont-Tremblant are among the municipalities that have adopted the rates set out in the provincial law.

Quebec Transport Minister André Fortin said the goal of the new rules is to allow police officers the ability to levy heftier fines when drivers are parked in an unsafe manner, such as on a sidewalk or in front of a fire hydrant — "not when you're illegally parked on a residential street."

He said perhaps the Highway Safety Code needs to be modified to make that clearer, but his ministry will first check in with municipalities.

"We want to make sure that we have the same understanding," Fortin said.

"We will at least ensure that all municipalities know that the Highway Safety Code does not necessarily take precedence over their parking regulations, that they can continue to proceed as they have always done."

With files from Radio-Canada's Thomas Gerbet and CBC's Antoni Nerestant