Ottawa

'Time stopped for me': Witness describes aftermath of fatal boat crash

A resident of a home on a lake north of Kingston., Ont., where three people died in a boat crash is shaken after he and his brother were among the first to respond to the collision.

Crash happened on Bobs Lake after 9:30 p.m. Saturday

A police boat and divers in the water.
Members of the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) search the water at Buck Bay on May 21, 2024, following a fatal boat crash over the long weekend. (Dan Taekema/CBC)

A resident of a home on a lake north of Kingston, Ont., where three people died in a boat crash is shaken after he and his brother were among the first to respond to the collision.

Ontario Provincial Police say the crash happened in the Buck Bay area of Bobs Lake after 9:30 p.m. Saturday, involving "an open bow fishing-style boat" and a speedboat.

Three people were pronounced dead at the scene, including a 21-year-old woman and 23-year-old man from South Frontenac Township, and a 22-year-old woman from Elginburg, Ont. OPP say five other people between the ages of 21 and 44 were taken to hospital in Kingston with various injuries.

'I wish we could have done more'

Tony Hammond, who lives on Bobs Lake, heard the crash Saturday from his cottage deck.

He had seen a group of young people on a fishing boat across the bay earlier that evening. He said they were playing music and having a good time. 

Then he heard the distinctive roar of a speed boat's engine and the sound of the crash.

"We heard the crunch," Hammond told CBC on Monday. "Time stopped for me."

One grey and one orange boat sit in the water next to a grassy shore. Both boats are clearly damaged, and the orange boat is partially on top of the grey one.
Two boats collided on Bobs Lake, north of Kingston, Ont., Saturday night, prompting the director of the Canadian Safe Boating Council to warn boaters they should take extra safety precautions at night. (Tony Hammond)

He rushed to phone 911, then took a boat out onto the water to survey the situation along with his brother. 

Hammond said they found debris and a woman's body in the lake. They attempted to perform CPR to resuscitate her, though they were unsuccessful. 

"We got her out as fast as humanly possible," he recalled. "There were no signs of life." 

Hammond said he continued searching the waters for another 30 to 45 minutes, until search and rescue arrived, but he only had a flashlight. 

"I wish we could have done more," he said. 

'Boat responsibly,' boating safety expert urges

Frontenac OPP are investigating the incident, assisted by a collision reconstructionist and members of the technical collision investigation team. Police say the collision reconstructionist will work to examine both boats.

On Tuesday, OPP officers could be seen scouring the site of the crash.

Police divers searched the water for evidence that may have sunk following the collision.

"There might be a lot of debris, marks, evidence, things like that, that need to be collected for the investigation to conclude ... what the cause of this collision is, whether it's speed-related, life-jacket usage or [non-]usage, and different factors," said Const. Rob Martell Tuesday.

"An incident like this does hit pretty hard on the local community."

On Tuesday evening, OPP said on social media they've completed their on-site investigation and regular marine traffic can continue on Bobs Lake.

Police divers hand over an object to police on a boat.
Divers with the OPP search Buck Bay on Tuesday, and hand over an object to police on board a boat. (Dan Taekema/CBC)

Boating at night can be a challenge, a safety expert said. 

"When you're boating out there at night, you really have to be cognisant of other people that could be out there," said Ian Gilson, director of the Canadian Safe Boating Council.

Visibility is reduced at night — an effect that can be amplified due to glare caused by boat lights, other surrounding lights and the increased risk of fog in the spring and summer months that often results from varying air and water temperatures, Gilson explained.

He said boaters should always wear a life-jacket and boat sober.

A lake on a sunny spring day.
The calm waters of Bobs Lake north of Kingston, Ont., on May 19, 2024. The night before, two boats collided on the lake, killing three people and injuring five others. (Camille Kasisi-Monet/Radio-Canada)

At night, additional safety considerations are required. Boaters should ensure that their boat lights are on and that they're advancing at a cautious speed. It's also important, he said, that boaters remain alert in case sounds or sights of approaching boaters emerge. 

Gilson emphasized the Canadian Safe Boating Council wants people to enjoy boating. But in order for it to be a pleasurable experience, he said, it's important boaters "respect" the water and be mindful of their surroundings.

"Just don't do risky things ... and just boat responsibly."

WATCH | Neighbour tried to help after fatal boat crash: 

Neighbour rushed to help after deadly Ontario boat crash

6 months ago
Duration 1:48
A cottager who heard the impact of a boat crash from across Bobs Lake in eastern Ontario rushed to help, and says that night is seared into his memory. Three people were killed and five others were injured in the long weekend collision.

With files from Kimberley Molina, Jodie Applewaithe and Dan Taekema