Ottawa·Phoenix Falling

Merry Christmas! Government claws back dad's pay advance over holiday

Manager Dean Ashby is experiencing his own nightmare before Christmas, thanks to the Phoenix pay system. His next three paycheques over the holidays are being clawed back to repay the government for a salary advance, but he still is owed money.

'It's not nice. Let me get my head above water first.'

People gather around the Centennial Flame on Parliament Hill in Ottawa. (Fred Chartrand/Canadian Press)

Dean Ashby is experiencing his own nightmare before Christmas, thanks to ongoing Phoenix pay problems. The father of two had to break the news to his children that there won't be many presents under the tree this year. 

"I'm stressed," said Ashby. "My blood pressure is through the roof. I'm ready to give up."

Why would you do it at Christmas? It's not nice- Dean Ashby, Manager at Measurement Canada 

The Measurement Canada manager received an email confirming the government is clawing back most of his next three paycheques over the holidays. 

"It's very disheartening when you look at your paycheque for the two weeks before Christmas and it's $600," said Ashby in Penticton, B.C. "My mortgage is more than I'm going to get paid over the next month."
Measurement Canada manager Dean Ashby says he's owed as much as $1,500 for missing pay. (Submitted)

Ashby took a $3,500 salary advance to pay his mortgage in the summer after not getting paid for seven pay periods. Now, more than half a year later, the government is taking that money back. 

"Why would you do it at Christmas? It's not nice. Let me get my head above water first. You still owe me," he said.

Ashby estimates the government owes him $1,500 for missing pay and thousands of dollars in benefits.

Since returning from leave April 1, Ashby hasn't had extended medical coverage due to problems with Phoenix. He has had to pay out of pocket for his daughter's low-dosage chemotherapy medication for rheumatoid arthritis. 

"We've got thousands upon thousands [of dollars] in prescriptions we haven't been able to claim," said Ashby. "In the end I'm wishing I'd never taken it because it's a hardship more than anything."

Late processing to blame

Public Services and Procurement Canada told Ashby in an email that they should have taken back the salary advance earlier, but didn't. 

As of Nov.16 the government is clawing back all salary advances taken by employees now getting paid, according to an "emergency salary advance" memo from PSPC sent to public servants. 

PSPC Deputy Minister Marie Lemay says the government is not meeting service standards in responding to pay requests at a technical briefing on Dec.14. (CBC)

On Wednesday, the department's deputy minister sent a message to those experiencing pay problems heading into the holidays.

"This has been a very challenging year and I understand how difficult the situation continues to be," said Marie Lemay. "Your patience and tolerance are deeply appreciated. Please know that our top priority remains to provide you with support and to resolve the problems."

"I want to remind employees that there is absolutely no reason you should go without your pay. You can ask for a salary advance for missing pay."

Ashby says that offer doesn't help him at all. He has already taken out a salary advance and says taking out a second one would be like paying off one credit card with another.

Meanwhile, Lemay says a review of the Phoenix system could take until the spring of 2017 to complete.