PEI

Talking politics with family and friends? Start with curiosity and respect, says P.E.I. psychologist

The federal election is coming up on April 28, and campaigns can stir up lots of opinion and emotions. 

It's important to talk honestly and not avoid tough issues, says Dr. Brent Macdonald

illustrated image of a couple standing back to back with their arms crossed
Talking about politics with your loved ones can be divisive, but there are ways to state your opinions while preserving relationships. (Credit: iStock/Getty Images)

The federal election is coming up on April 28, and campaigns can stir up lots of opinion and emotions. 

The political climate in Canada and abroad has been especially polarizing lately, so you may find yourself disagreeing with friends and family when discussing the issues.  

"A big part of that is social media and the echo chamber that we find ourselves in when we start liking certain stories or browsing on certain media sources that start feeding us more and more literature… that satisfy our needs, but polarize the opposite end of the spectrum, leading to all sorts of conflict," psychologist Dr. Brent Macdonald said in an interview with Sheehan Desjardins on CBC News: Compass

The reason for all that passion leading up to this election? Because the ramifications could intimately impact our daily lives, Macdonald said. 

Rather than domestic issues, U.S. President Donald Trump's trade war with nations including Canada has been the key focus of this campaign. 

The American administration's tariffs threaten lots of things here at home, from the price of gas to the cost of groceries and housing to Canada's very sovereignty

WATCH | How to talk to friends and relatives about politics without causing or deepening division:

How to talk to friends and relatives about politics without causing or deepening division

6 days ago
Duration 6:42
The federal election is coming up on April 28, and campaigns can stir up both opinions and emotions. Politics is polarizing, and disagreeing with your family and friends can be tough. Dr. Brent Macdonald joins Sheehan Desjardins of CBC News: Compass to talk about ways to state your opinions while preserving relationships.

The party whose policies are best suited to cope with the issues may seem obvious to you, but discovering opposing opinions in your close personal circle can almost short-circuit the brain.  

"You have to think, you have to rationalize, you have to research and have some idea of what it is you're trying to communicate to the other person who has a very different perspective," Macdonald said. "That's hard work, it's frustrating, and we end up getting upset with each other." 

There's a common axiom that we shouldn't talk politics around the family dinner table. Macdonald doesn't think that's the best approach, though. 

A yellow lawn sign reading 'Elections Canada: Vote' is shown, with a blue sky and bridge in the background.
Canadians go to the polls in the federal election on April 28. (Mark Blinch/Reuters)

"If we don't talk about things and we just avoid them, that's not helpful either…. We're not confronting and challenging the perceptions that we may disagree with," he said. "It's OK to disagree… It just becomes a bit more problematic when it's people with whom you have a close relationship."

These discussions can create anxiety and avoidance, but it's not healthy to let them sink in. 

Macdonald's advice is to approach such conversations respectfully, honestly and with genuine curiosity about how the other person arrived at their point of view, "knowing that the person… above all still loves you, still respects you, may disagree with you on that one position, but that's OK. We're allowed to do that."

A man smiles against a black background.
Dr. Brent Macdonald says it's important to approach political disagreements with curiosity about how the other person arrived at their viewpoints. (Submitted by Brent Macdonald)

If there's one positive to take from the recent turmoil from south of the border, Macdonald said, it's that it seems to have brought Canadians of many political stripes closer together. 

And if folks from the left wing, the right wing and every political stripe in between are finding common ground, families and friends can certainly do it too. 

"If someone's threatening us, we seek out support from those who are close to us," Macdonald said. 

"People who would be competitors previously are now working with one another because we see that there is a common threat that we have to approach in a reasonable way and in a fair way." 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Stephen Brun

Journalist

Stephen Brun works for CBC in Charlottetown, P.E.I. Through the years he has been a writer and editor for a number of newspapers and news sites across Canada, most recently in the Atlantic region. You can reach him at stephen.brun@cbc.ca.

With files from CBC News: Compass