Sudbury

Outside firms bid to build Sudbury's new arena, some in partnership with local architects

Two of Sudbury, Ont.’s most experienced architecture firms say they would not have met the request for proposal requirements of the project had they not partnered up with larger companies.

Local firms join forces with larger companies in hopes of being selected to design the project

An ice rink with empty seats.
The City of Greater Sudbury is in the early stages of replacing its 70-year-old community arena, having opened up the bidding process to design a new $200-million event centre earlier this summer. (Yvon Theriault/Radio-Canada)

It's a project Greater Sudbury city council has talked about for decades, so naturally, local architects have been imagining what a new arena or event centre could look like for a long time. 

While no local names appeared on the northern Ontario city's recent list of bids submitted for the architectural design of the $200-million project, some Sudbury firms say that doesn't necessarily mean they won't be involved. 

At least two say they've had to partner up with larger, outside firms to qualify for the proposal stage.

"To be in a position to win the project, you had to demonstrate that you've done three arena projects of similar size and complexity," said Tim James of 3rdLine Studio.

A group of people pose for a team portrait.
Tim James, left, has practised architecture with 3rdLine.Studio in northern Ontario for over 30 years. (Submitted by 3rdLine.Studio)

"There aren't any Sudbury based architectural firms that have that kind of layer of experience." 

3rdLine Studio partnered with Toronto's Perkins + Will for their bid. They partnered with that firm for past downtown projects like the YMCA and federal government buildings.

"Our approach has always been to split the project 50/50," said James. 

One of Sudbury's oldest architecture firms, Bélanger Salach Architecture, has employed a similar strategy for its bid. 

If selected for the project, the company would also be dividing the work equally with U.S. corporation, Populous. 

Architect Amber Salach says this is an efficient way to do it  — one partner with local expertise and boots on the ground, and the other with international experience and expertise in arenas.

"I think most firms are feeling this is the best approach to bring this project to life," she said. 

This project almost feels personal, says local architect

Both say being selected to design the new arena would be the project of a life time. 

"We're very excited about the momentum it's gained in the past few months, with the purchasing of properties and the revitalization of the downtown master plan," said Salach. 

Portrait of a woman.
Amber Salach is an architect with Bélanger Salach Architecture in Sudbury. The firm is celebrating 60 years in business this year. (Submitted by Bélanger Salach Architecture)

As for James, he said the project almost feels personal for Sudbury's architects. 

"It always felt like the arena had to be in the downtown core," he said, referring to the decade-old debate on where the new arena should be built. 

"We're so excited and impressed it's all finally coming together."

The other architectural firms proposing to design Sudbury's new event centre are DIALOG Alberta, Brisbin Brook Beynon and ZAS architects. 

Some of the other Sudbury firms that applied with the city to get the plans for the bid include Caritas Development, Centreline Architecture, Danielson Architecture, Perry + Perry and Luciw Boudreau Architecture. It is unclear who has partnered with the five final bidders.

City staff anticipate that an agreement for Architectural Services would be executed before the end of November, according to a report currently up before city council.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Aya Dufour

reporter

Aya Dufour is a CBC reporter based in northern Ontario. She welcomes comments, ideas, criticism, jokes and compliments: aya.dufour@cbc.ca