Toronto

Councillor wants to explore more food options in Toronto parks, fewer rules

A city councillor wants to see more creativity, fewer rules and maybe a few places to grab a bite to eat in Toronto's parks.

Coun. Josh Matlow is asking for a review of outdated park bylaws

Picnic bans? No frisbee? One councillor thinks Toronto's park rules go too far

19 hours ago
Duration 2:24
Toronto park-goers are subject to many rules — specifically around sports and picnics. But as CBC's Lane Harrison explains, one city councillor thinks it's time to change that.

A city councillor wants to see more creativity, fewer rules and maybe a few places to grab a bite to eat in Toronto's parks.

Coun. Josh Matlow is asking city staff to undertake a review of the city's park rules to see which ones are archaic, burdensome or unnecessary. He also wants them to explore ways to introduce more food and beverage options to the city's parks, like kiosks or small cafes. 

Matlow is bringing forward the motion after a resident sent him a photo of a sign in a city park that said picnics, kite flying, ball playing and frisbee throwing are prohibited without permits and that cyclists need to get off their bikes on hills. 

While the city's bylaws state those permitting rules are only for groups of 25 or more, that detail is found in the bylaw documents, not on the sign itself. That bylaw includes other rules for things kids may want to do, like climb a tree, but says they can't without a permit. 

"I've got a 12-year-old daughter, I would rather her climb a tree any day than spend the whole day on a screen," Matlow said in an interview with CBC Toronto. He said he wants to modernize the city's bylaws so people know they can come to parks and enjoy themselves, as long as they respect rules that should exist.

"In other words, don't behave in ways that have an adverse effect on other people around you, then come have a good time because these parks are yours." 

Watch | Toronto crews under fire for poor mainteance:

Toronto councillor reacts to 'damning' AG parks maintenance report

7 months ago
Duration 2:35
Toronto’s auditor general has released a report that found city crews were over-reporting time spent maintaining local parks. Metro Morning host David Common spoke with Coun. Brad Bradford about how the report might affect public trust, and the city’s next steps.

Matlow's motion will go before city council when it meets later this week. He said making parks enjoyable is paramount in a city where many people don't have backyards. 

He's not the first councillor to call out the city's rules in public parks. Last winter, Coun. Brad Bradford raised concerns about rules prohibiting tobogganing in parks. 

Making parks more inclusive

The city should be ensuring that it's approaching park rules in a way that makes the spaces accessible to everyone, said Erika Nikolai, executive director of national advocacy group Park People. 

"Thinking about how people are going to interpret them, how some rules may impact some communities more than others," she said. 

"So really thinking about how they can be inclusive and welcoming and making sure that communities are maximizing the incredible benefits that Toronto's parks offer to our communities."

People take photos of the cherry blossoms at Trinity Bellwoods Park, in Toronto, on May 5, 2022.
Coun. Josh Matlow's motion will go before city council when it meets on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday. He said making parks enjoyable is paramount in a city where many people don’t have backyards.  (Alex Lupul/CBC)

This is an issue on Matlow's mind too, especially when it comes to picnics. He said some newcomers to the country want to obey the rules but also have large family gatherings. 

"They're not hurting anybody, they're having fun together, and we want people to enjoy themselves in our parks and socialize. I mean, that's a healthy society," he said. 

Matlow's motion follows a March staff report on the city's alcohol in parks pilot project. The report found it to be a success so far, with minimal disruption and positive feedback from residents. 

Exploring more food options

Now, Matlow wants Toronto to go further and bring itself in line with other large cities around the world by expanding food options in parks.

"Often you can have it in a place that's appropriate with some cafe tables, people watching, it's a fun place to hang out and see friends," he said. 

Matlow used Bryant Park in New York City as an example, where an outdoor cafe hosts an after-work happy hour and a variety of food. 

"I don't want the city managing our parks. I want the city being visionaries. I want us to look around the world, look for best practices that are working and then adopt them here."



 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Lane Harrison is a reporter with CBC Toronto who primarily covers municipal and provincial politics. Born and raised in Toronto, he joined CBC in 2022 as a Joan Donaldson Scholar after an internship with the Globe and Mail. You can reach him at lane.harrison@cbc.ca