World·CBC in India

Pandemic has devastated India's economy and left its children vulnerable to exploitation as cheap labour

With 9.6 million COVID-19 cases, India has the second-highest caseload in the world after the U.S. The pandemic has devastated the country's economy and created fertile ground for exploitation of children, who are being pressed into hard labour as desperate families struggle to survive.

India has 2nd highest caseload in the world, with 9.6 million COVID-19 cases and close to 140,000 deaths

A boy whose family is living on the streets of south Delhi, India. The country's economy has taken a big hit from the pandemic, and children have become a source of cheap labour. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

Ajay Tomar regularly scans the platforms of the New Delhi Railway Station, the busiest in India, running through a checklist in his head. 

The social worker is trained to spot signs of children being trafficked into forced labour. One telltale sign is seeing one or two kids are surrounded by a group of adults, the children isolated. He always glances at their hands to check if they are worn, a clue the child has been working illegally. 

Child labour is illegal in India for anyone under 14 except in special circumstances, such as working for a family business. But it's a problem that has been exacerbated by the coronavirus pandemic, with indications pointing to a sharp increase in the number of children being exploited as cheap labourers. 

India's last census, in 2011, showed the country had nearly 8.2 million child labourers between the ages of five and 14, mainly in the country's poor rural states, such as Bihar and Uttar Pradesh. Children's rights groups say that number improved significantly this past decade but fear the pandemic will reverse much of that progress.

A 10-year-old boy works inside a lime paste factory in a Mumbai slum in November 2010. Child advocates say that the child labour situation has improved in the past decade but worry that progress will be set back as the pandemic economy forces children back to work. (Danish Siddiqui/Reuters)

India's swift and severe lockdown to stop the spread of COVID-19, imposed in March with mere hours' notice, made a desperate situation worse and created "fertile ground" for traffickers, according to Sudarshan Suchi, CEO of Save the Children India. 

It abruptly shut all of the country's schools and forced migrant labourers out of work, Suchi said, and once the measures started to ease, industry turned to the cheapest labour available to make up the shortfall: children.   

Children who have missed their online classes due to a lack of internet facilities sit on the ground maintain a safe distance as they listen to pre-recorded lessons over loudspeakers in Dandwal village in the western state of Maharashtra. (Prashant Waydande/Reuters)

Schools in many parts of the country remain shut

The country has the second-highest number of COVID-19 cases after the U.S., at 9.6 million, and third-highest number of deaths, at almost 140,000.

Reopening orders vary from state to state, but schools across the country are still closed or operating at a much-reduced capacity, and children in some of India's poorer communities are not in class because they don't have access to online learning.  

Children watch online lectures inside a digital mobile education library in Mumbai set up so that children without access to cellphones can follow classes virtually during the pandemic. Schools in many part of India are closed as COVID-19 cases show no sign of slowing down. (Francis Mascarenhas/Reuters)

On the heels of its deadliest month from COVID-19 cases, Delhi's Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia said schools would remain shut until a vaccine is available. 

In other states, such as Gujarat, classes were set to resume in late November before authorities, spooked by a rise in infections, decided to hold off. 

As a result, Suchi said, his crews have seen a "marked increase" in child labour in urban and rural areas, where children are often pushed into working at garment factories, car repair shops or garbage dumps, where they pick out plastics to earn a few cents.  

"The vulnerability is at its highest right now," he said. 

Suchi also worries the damage has already been done, since once children from poorer communities leave class for work, it's much harder for them to return.

WATCH | In pandemic, children have become source of cheap labour in some parts of India:

Children in India made more vulnerable by COVID-19 pandemic

4 years ago
Duration 2:32
In India, with a COVID-19 case count second only to the U.S., it's children who've become the cheapest and easiest sources of income for families ravaged by economic fallout.

Families complicit in child labour

Tomar, who works for the Delhi-based non-governmental organization Prayas, has been seeing more of that vulnerability, too, as families turn to children to help scrape together enough money to survive.

"We find kids here who have come to work … with their fathers and mothers," Tomar said.

While he was speaking to CBC News, Tomar's fellow social workers on the railway rescue team were interviewing a preteen boy who tried to run away from the two adults who had forced him into manual labour. One of them was his cousin; the other his brother.

Two small children stand on a platform next to railway tracks.
Kids on the platform at the New Delhi Railway Station. Workers from the Prayas Juvenile Aid Centre Society patrol the station on the lookout for children who are being forced to work illegally by adults. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

The boy eventually told the social workers that his relatives forced him to work 14 days in a row at a bicycle-chain repair factory near the New Delhi train station until he got so tired he tried to travel back to his home state of Bihar, hundreds of kilometres away, to see his mother. His captors tailed him to the station, where Tomar's team noticed the group and intervened. 

Tomar said the fact the boy's brother was involved in forcing him to work is all too common.

"We find out every day that families are almost all OK [with it]," said Tomar. "We can't say anything to them. They are vulnerable, marginalized people." 

Ajay Tomar, a social worker with Prayas, believes during the pandemic, some children he would have normally been able to rescue may be slipping through the cracks. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

Economy contracted 24% during pandemic

Chaman Shagufta, who works as a counsellor with the same organization at a children's shelter in one of Delhi's poorest neighbourhoods, knows that all too well. 

She often has to tease the stories out of the children and track inconsistencies before handing their files over to India's child welfare authorities, who determine if a child should be allowed to return to their family or be sent to a shelter.

Shagufta's rapid-fire questions, punctuated by terms of endearment, are effective in getting two young boys picked up at the New Delhi Railway Station on their way to Maharashtra from the poverty-plagued state of Bihar to tell part of their story.

"Before the lockdown, we were in school," said one boy.

Boys at one of the 38 children's homes and shelters run by Prayas practise drawing and the alphabet. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

He insisted he was 15, but Shagufta was unconvinced, suspecting the boy was closer to 12. 

"It's very much a probability that they have come for work since schools are locked down and nobody is studying," she said. 

Many parents know children are being sent off to work, she said, and reason that they may as well "earn something" during the shutdown period. 

It's a sign of the dire straits families are in in an economy that has contracted 24 per cent between April and June of this year, according to government GDP figures. 

Children near a street corner in central Delhi where they beg for money from drivers stuck in traffic. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

'Nowhere children'

Children are most at risk under those circumstances, said Amod Kanth, the former Delhi police officer who founded the NGO Prayas. 

"I prefer to call them 'nowhere children,' he said. "They are not on the radar. They are not visible. They are not accounted for because they happen to be drifting, traveling, migrating.

"They suffer more compared to others in the pandemic."

Amod Kanth, a former New Delhi police officer who founded Prayas, says children 'are not on the radar' during the pandemic and suffer more as a result. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

In another children's home operated by Prayas, Poonam waits patiently for a quick visit in the hallway outside the large room where her three eldest children are getting an art lesson from social workers. 

The 30-year old mother of four boys lives in one of Delhi's poorest slums and told CBC News the eight months since the start of India's lockdown order were the hardest she's had to endure. 

"It was tough," she said. "My children were starving."

Her husband, an addict, had already left her and she was also caring for her own mother, who has health problems.    

Poonam is a 30-year-old mother of four who works selling vegetables. During the pandemic, she has only been able to earn less than $3 a day. She says she had no choice but to let her children beg for money in order to survive. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

Desperation pushed her to send three of her sons, ages 5, 7 and 11, to beg on the streets outside a local temple and at busy intersections while she ran her vegetable stand, making about 150 rupees (less than $3 Cdn) a day, she said. 

Only, fewer people were out buying vegetables and the struggle to find enough money for the family to eat was crushing.

The boys were spotted begging a month ago and taken in by social workers, who alerted the authorities and started the child welfare committee process to determine whether the three can be sent home. 

They are living temporarily at the Prayas shelter, and Poonam desperately wants to keep it that way. 

"It's too hard. They will die if they come back to me," Poonam said, her voice breaking with emotion.

At a home for vulnerable children in northeast Delhi, boys learn handicraft skills. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Salimah Shivji

Journalist

Salimah Shivji is CBC's South Asia correspondent, based in Mumbai. She has covered everything from natural disasters and conflicts, climate change to corruption across Canada and the world in her nearly two decades with the CBC.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Your daily guide to the coronavirus outbreak. Get the latest news, tips on prevention and your coronavirus questions answered every evening.

...

The next issue of the Coronavirus Brief will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in the Subscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.