New Brunswick

PC health minister says Higgs shouldn't call early election

A senior provincial cabinet minister who has remained loyal to Premier Blaine Higgs is saying there’s no need for the premier to call an early election this fall.

Bruce Fitch says Tory caucus should try to work together before premier goes to the polls

A man standing in a pharmacy, speaking, as others look on.
Health Minister Bruce Fitch says there should be a way to resolve the premier's concerns without calling an early election. (Jonathan Collicott/CBC)

A senior provincial cabinet minister who has remained loyal to Premier Blaine Higgs is saying there's no need for the premier to call an early election this fall.

Health Minister Bruce Fitch said he'd prefer to see Higgs work with his caucus, including six Progressive Conservative MLAs unhappy with his leadership, rather than going to the polls a year early.

"I don't think we need an election. There's another year in that mandate," Fitch told Radio-Canada, pointing out that it's up to Higgs to make the decision.

The premier has hinted he may need to call an election because of the six MLAs who voted with the opposition Liberals in June on Policy 713.

A man with grey hair and glasses wearing a suit and standing at a wooden podium.
Premier Blaine Higgs rejected a pledge by six Progressive Conservative MLAs to support his legislation this fall so he can avoid an early election call. (Pat Richard/CBC)

Those MLAs have committed to supporting PC legislation this fall but also say they want the caucus to have more input into decision-making.

Fitch says there should be a way to resolve that without an election. 

"You know, we talked about needs and wants," he said, borrowing a phrase Higgs coined in 2010 to describe his fiscal philosophy.

"Do we need one? I think we could work in collaboration with our caucus before going into an election. But again, I will leave that up to the premier."

WATCH | PC health minister says Higgs should not call election:

Higgs’s health minister says no election needed this fall

2 years ago
Duration 0:48
Bruce Fitch says premier should work to overcome caucus turmoil rather than go to the polls.

The six rebellious MLAs say Higgs has rebuffed their requests for a meeting of the full PC caucus since June.

Fitch, speaking after a ceremony to mark the naming of a bridge after the late MLA and minister Brenda Robertson, also hinted he won't run in the next election. 

He was first elected as MLA for Riverview in 2003 and was a town councillor and mayor before that.

As an MLA he served in the cabinets of three PC premiers and was also interim leader of the party and the leader of the official opposition from 2014 to 2016. 

"That's 35 years as an elected official altogether, so if I decide to take a break, I don't think anyone should fault me on that," he said.

Kris Austin, wearing glasses, a black blazer and blue dress shirt, looks off camera.
Public Safety Minister Kris Austin says he's ready to go should the premier call an election. (Ed Hunter/CBC)

Other ministers who attended Thursday's bridge announcement were more enthused about a snap election this fall.

"I've told him whatever he decides to do, I respect, and I'll certainly be ready to go," Public Safety Minister Kris Austin said.

"I support the premier and his vision and what he's been doing in New Brunswick."

Women's Equality Minister Sherry Wilson said she will "absolutely" run in the next election, whenever it is.

Her Moncton Southwest riding was split up in the new electoral boundaries map so Wilson plans to run in Arcadia-Butternut-Maple Hills, a riding that stretches from the outskirts of Moncton to the village of Gagetown, including the communities of Havelock and Cambridge Narrows.

A smiling woman with short blond hair
Sherry Wilson, the minister responsible for women’s equality, says she will run again. Wilson backed Higgs during caucus turmoil over Policy 713. (Radio-Canada)

Wilson and Austin backed Higgs in the spring during caucus turmoil over Policy 713, which sets out guidelines for creating safe, inclusive spaces for LGBTQ students in provincial schools.

Fitch was less vocal but he opted not to join the group of six PC MLAs who voted against Higgs on the issue. 

Fitch was shuffled into the health portfolio in July 2022 at the same time Higgs suspended the boards of the two provincial health authorities and fired Horizon Health CEO Dr. John Dornan.

The premier made those moves in the wake of a high-profile death in the emergency department of the Dr. Everett Chalmers Regional Hospital in Fredericton. 

On Thursday  Fitch wouldn't comment on the turmoil in the PC caucus since then.

"I think it's been described pretty well in the media and I don't think I can add anything, any more insights than have already been talked about."

The minister said he'd been suffering from a cold and said Higgs has also been ill this week. 

"There's a lot of viruses going around now, at this point in time," he said. 

Higgs's office did not respond immediately to a request for a comment on what Fitch said.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jacques Poitras

Provincial Affairs reporter

Jacques Poitras has been CBC's provincial affairs reporter in New Brunswick since 2000. He grew up in Moncton and covered Parliament in Ottawa for the New Brunswick Telegraph-Journal. He has reported on every New Brunswick election since 1995 and won awards from the Radio Television Digital News Association, the National Newspaper Awards and Amnesty International. He is also the author of five non-fiction books about New Brunswick politics and history.

With files from Michèle Brideau, Radio-Canada