NL

Scathing resignation letter not related to byelection campaign: former district president

Darryl Harding says his decision to run as an Independent in this month's Conception Bay East-Bell Island byelection has nothing to do with the letter he sent accusing Progressive Conservative Leader Tony Wakeham of cherry-picking the party's candidate.

Darryl Harding accused PC Leader Tony Wakeham of cherry-picking the party's candidate

A man wearing a blue plaid shirt and black glasses sits in front of a beige wall and a window with white curtains.
Darryl Harding insists his decision to run as an independent in the Conception Bay East-Bell Island byelection has nothing to do with the blistering resignation letter he sent accusing Progressive Conservative Leader Tony Wakeham of cherry-picking the party’s candidate. (Ted Dillon/CBC)

The former Progressive Conservative district association president for Conception Bay East-Bell Island says a blistering resignation letter he sent to the party has nothing to do with his decision to run as an Independent in the district's upcoming byelection.

Almost two months ago, Darryl Harding sent a letter to the PC party accusing Leader Tony Wakeham of cherry-picking the party's candidate, Tina Neary, whom he currently works with as a town councillor for Portugal Cove-St. Philip's.

"No candidate from any other party, my feelings about those candidates, or my feelings about those parties played any role in my final decision to offer myself in this byelection," said Harding, one of four candidates in the Jan. 29 byelection. 

Harding didn't mince his words in the letter, accusing Wakeham of choosing a supporter of his as the byelection candidate and saying he surrounds himself with "incompetent" advisors. He also said PC leaders have surrounded themselves with "lackeys" and "yes-men" for the past 15 years.

But he says he doesn't want any of that to become an election issue. The letter was supposed to be internal, and despite his strong language and pointed criticisms, he says he expected it would stay within the party.

In an interview with CBC News, he said he didn't want to discuss the letter further because he thinks it would "hurt the party and it would hurt the candidate."

"I'll address all of this after the election because it's unfair," said Harding.

Change of mind

Harding says he initially wasn't planning on running because he wanted to fulfil his four-year commitment to the people that voted him onto Portugal Cove-St. Philip's town council and he didn't want to burden the town with the cost of a municipal byelection if he were to win.

After posting about his intentions not to run on social media, he said, many people reached out to him, including those who are "politically astute," telling him that as an MHA, he could continue to help both his municipality and other districts.

Harding said he reconsidered, and if he's "lucky enough" to win, he'll shell out cash from his MHA salary to pay the town back for the cost of a byelection.

WATCH | Darryl Harding refuses to talk about scathing letter sent to PCs: 

Darryl Harding insists he’s not trying to stick it to the PCs by running as an Independent

10 months ago
Duration 2:07
Almost two months ago, Darryl Harding sent a scathing letter accusing Newfoundland and Labrador Progressive Conservative Leader Tony Wakeham of cherry-picking the party’s candidate for the upcoming Conception Bay East-Bell Island byelection. Now the former PC district association president is running in the byelection an independent.

Although he says there are disadvantages running as an Independent, Harding says he spent a lot of time — around 15 years — working closely with former interim PC leader David Brazil, someone he says he loves and is a "salt of the earth person."

Brazil, who was interim leader of the PCs for two and a half years, held the metro-area seat as a Tory stronghold from 2010 until the end of 2023. 

Also competing in the byelection are Liberal Fred Hutton, a senior aide to Premier Andrey Furey, and New Democrat Kim Churchill, a human rights advocate well known for fighting for rights of deaf and hard-of-hearing students. 

A man and two women pose in front of a curtain. All three are smiling.
Liberal candidate Fred Hutton, left, Progressive Conservative Tina Neary and New Democrat Kim Churchill took part in a debate this month on Bell Island. Harding did not attend because of a death in the family. (William Ping/CBC)

Harding said he has a chance to win the byelection because of the connections he's made throughout the district and through his "acts of social activities, if you will, and supporting people."

Harding said he's been a "conservative person" his whole life and has been transparent about it from the beginning of his campaign. Even though he's running as an Independent, he said, he wants the public to know that "this Darryl J. Harding is the same person that they already know."

"I'm not trying to ride anyone's coattails or do anybody any harm," he added. "I'm just putting myself out there."

As an MHA, he says some of the issues he'd like to focus on are getting a shore manager for Bell Island, solving Bell Island's water supply issues, building a high school in Paradise, and bringing a better water and sewer system to Portugal Cove-St. Philip's.

He says the district as a whole needs to reopen the public health medical clinic and increase police presence on its roads.

GoFundMe and harassment controversies

Harding's time on Portugal Cove-St. Philip's town council has twice been controversial.

Last February, he was suspended from council committees after an external investigation found multiple people alleged he had harassed or sexually harassed them.

He was suspended from council last March after another investigation found he'd breached the town's code of conduct for soliciting donations from residents through a GoFundMe campaign after he was injured in a car crash.

Both suspensions were for three months from the date the decisions were made.

Harding went to the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador to challenge both suspensions. 

When asked if Neary was one of the councillors who voted to have him suspended during the GoFundMe investigation, which Harding says is still before the courts, he says he can't say for certain whether Neary voted.

"It has no reflection on my candidacy, none of that stuff," he said. "I'm more mature than that."

Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Click here to visit our landing page.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jessica Singer is a journalist with CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. She has worked in CBC newsrooms in Toronto and St. John's. You can reach her at jessica.singer@cbc.ca

With files from On The Go

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Subscribe to our daily newsletter for the top stories in Newfoundland and Labrador.

...

The next issue of CBC Newfoundland and Labrador newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in the Subscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.