NL

St. John's woman in wheelchair trapped inside home with no bathroom access

Rhonda Whalen is trapped in her public housing unit and can't access the bathroom upstairs because she uses a wheelchair.

Whalen using commode in kitchen, can only get outside with help of an ambulance

Whelan in a wheelchair in her kitchen.
Rhonda Whalen in the kitchen of her home. This is where she uses the bathroom, bathes and has her meals prepared. She is confined to the first floor of a two-storey public housing unit that the City of St. John's owns. (Heather Gillis/CBC)

A St. John's woman in a wheelchair says she's trapped in her public housing unit because there are dozens of stairs leading to the apartment on Carter's Hill.

But that's not the biggest obstacle in Rhonda Whalen's way.

It's the 15 stairs separating her and the bathroom on the second floor.

It means she has to use a commode in her kitchen, right next to her table and chairs and in the same room where her meals are cooked. 

"I need to go [to] a place where I can go into a regular bathroom," Whalen said.

A house on a hill with dozens of concrete steps in either direction.
There are dozens of stairs outside Rhonda Whalen's house that prevent her from leaving. (Heather Gillis/CBC)

Whalen lost her left leg from necrotizing fasciitis in December 2023 and then this past May she had a stroke affecting sensation on the right side of her body, her remaining leg, and her speech.  

"But when I came home from ... the hospital, I couldn't get up over the stairs," she said.

Whalen, who has home care for a stint in the morning and evening, says she can transfer herself from the wheelchair to the commode on her own, but it's difficult and it can tip. 

WATCH | Rhonda Whalen shows the barriers she faces in her home:

This St. John's woman can't access the bathroom in her city housing unit

2 months ago
Duration 3:56
Rhonda Whalen of St. John's says she's trapped in her public housing unit. Unable to access the upstairs because she uses a wheelchair has kept her from accessing the unit's bathroom. The CBC's Heather Gillis reports on the other barriers she faces.

"Most times I try to go myself. It's a lot of time for me to do it because I don't feel on this side," she said gesturing to the side of her body affected by the stroke.

Whalen says she does all her personal care in the kitchen, from washing her hands, brushing her teeth and bathing. 

She says she's requested a new, accessible public housing unit from the city of St. John's. 

"I'll ask, do they have anything, 'Nope, nothing available right now'," Whalen said.

No accessible units available, city says

St. John's Mayor Danny Breen denied an interview request from CBC News, however, in a statement spokesperson Jackie O'Brien wrote that the city only has 25 fully accessible housing units and there is no vacancy. 

O'Brien says the last time an accessible unit became available was last year.

"We understand the urgency in getting Ms. Whalen proper housing, and we have been exploring alternate accommodations with her. Unfortunately to date a solution has not been attainable and we still have no vacancies in fully accessible units," reads part of the statement. 

Rhonda Whalen inside her house, looking out the front door.
This is as far as Whalen can venture in her wheelchair, with the doorstep and concrete steps preventing her from going any further. (Heather Gillis/CBC)

The city says it is incentivizing the construction of more accessible units with $20,000 from the federal government's Housing Accelerator Fund for homeowners who want to make units accessible. 

But in the meantime, Whalen says she's trapped on the first floor of her apartment, until she can find an alternative.

"It feels horrible," she said. 

Whalen says she can't cook in the kitchen because she can't reach the knobs on the back of the stove and has a burn mark on her right forearm from trying. 

"It's just stressing me so much,"  Whalen said.

Whalen forced to give up granddaughter

On top of her mobility and housing challenges, Whalen says she can no longer care for her six-year-old granddaughter, Alexis, who has been her responsibility after her daughter died in a car crash.

She's had to find other living arrangements for the girl.

"Alexis has nothing or no one other than me," she said.

Whelan in a wheelchair with two children hugging her.
Whalen with two of her grandchildren, incuding Alexis (left), who she has cared for since she was an infant. (Submitted by Rhonda Whalen)

Whalen says her granddaughter can't sleep or play in the upstairs bedrooms without supervision, and she can't get up there to watch her.

"I miss her every single day, every night," Whalen said.

Before her illnesses, Whalen was active and could take her granddaughter out to the park or the mall to see a movie, but not anymore.

Isolated inside

These days, Whalen says the closest to the outside world she can get is the front door. 

She says the only way she leaves the house is by ambulance and is carried either up or down the stairs when she has a doctor's appointment. 

"I can't go to the grocery store. I can't take Alexis out to get ice cream," she said. 

Meanwhile, the sofa in the living room doubles as Whalen's bed because she can't reach the bedrooms upstairs.

Child with an outstrecthed hand feeding a horse.
Whalen is devastated that her granddaughter Alexis can no longer stay with her because she can't navigate the stairs to check on the child, if she should have an accident. (Submitted by Rhonda Whalen)

"It's very degrading," said NDP Leader Jim Dinn, who is Whalen's MHA and has been advocating for her.

Dinn said Whalen is isolated and he is calling on the City of St. John's, Newfoundland and Labrador Housing and Children, Seniors and Social Development to all work together to find an accessible housing solution or renovation options for Whalen.

"It's a tremendous disruption to her life and I would say it's affecting her physical health as well as her mental health well-being," Dinn said. 

Read more from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Heather Gillis

Journalist

Heather Gillis is a journalist based in St. John's. She has been working at CBC NL since March 2020, but has been reporting in Newfoundland and Labrador since 2011. Heather has a bachelor of journalism from the University of King's College and a bachelor of arts from Memorial University. You can reach her by email at Heather.Gillis@cbc.ca

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

Subscribe to our daily newsletter for the top stories in Newfoundland and Labrador.

...

The next issue of CBC Newfoundland and Labrador newsletter will soon be in your inbox.

Discover all CBC newsletters in the Subscription Centre.opens new window

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Google Terms of Service apply.