Paul Lane poised to vote against Liberal budget
Liberal MHA Paul Lane appears set on a collision course with his own government, after breaking from Liberal ranks on Wednesday afternoon.
Lane, a former PC who crossed the floor to become a Liberal only two years ago, said Wednesday he'll vote against his own government's budget unless significant changes are made to the financial plan.
I've chosen to stand with the people.- MHA Paul Lane
- Full coverage: Newfoundland and Labrador Budget 2016
- Thousands swarm Confederation Building for anti-budget protest
"I've been really struggling with the budget since day one to be honest," he said in an interview with CBC News late Wednesday evening.
"I had a fundamental decision to make: Do you vote the way your party would want you to vote? Or do you vote on behalf of the people that put you there? I've chosen to stand with the people."
Needs change
Lane says he's been flooded with feedback from constituents of Mount Pearl-Southlands since the budget was revealed on April 14.
He has a number of issues with the document, including the implementation of full-day Kindergarten in a tough fiscal year, but says the biggest problem was with the controversial Deficit Reduction Levy.
He wants that levy eliminated. He says the tax increases this year are too much, even if it was expected that some taxes would have to increase.
- Liberals feeling heat over unpopular deficit reduction levy
- Parties planning to filibuster deficit reduction levy in wake of complaints
Lane claims he was lobbying for changes to the budget from inside government, but in the last few days began to feel that no changes were going to be made.
"At that point in time, I had to do a lot of soul searching and decide which way I was going to go," he said.
"In the final analysis, I decided there was no way, in good conscience, I could support the levy. I don't believe that's what the people who voted for me would want me to do."
Breaking ranks
Earlier in the day, Lane voted against a Liberal move to neuter a non-binding resolution, put forward by the NDP, calling for the Deficit Reduction Levy to be eliminated immediately.
The Liberals had proposed an amendment to change the wording of the resolution, having it read that the levy should be eliminated as soon as possible.
That's the wording the Liberal party has used since the budget was released, promising it will repeal the levy as early as 2018.
He voted against that amendment, the only Liberal MHA to do so.
Comes with Consequences
If Lane follows through on his threat to vote against the budget, he will almost certainly face repercussions from his party's leadership.
It won't be the first time. Lane left the PCs in 2014 under similar circumstances, when that party was taking a big hit in public opinion.
In a January announcement in a Mount Pearl restaurant, he said he had lost confidence in then-premier Kathy Dunderdale, who resigned a short time later.
Lane says he doesn't want to be removed from the Liberal caucus, but it's not entirely his decision.
"As a person who was duly elected by the people, I feel that I should have the right to vote on their behalf and to represent their wishes," he said .
"I know that traditionally that's not the way that it always goes, and I guess [a removal] would be the premier's call to make, not mine."
Discontent
The MHA said he has made his unhappiness with the budget clear to the Liberal caucus, but did not give them notice he'd be breaking ranks with them on Wednesday.
I've been more than vocal about how I feel.- Paul Lane
Lane said he hasn't been speaking with other caucus members since he cast his vote on Wednesday, but he doesn't think they were surprised.
- Liberals bending to budget criticism, but will they break?
- Here & Now: Don't expect big budget changes, Dwight Ball says
"I've been more than vocal about how I feel," he said.
A spokesperson for the premier said Dwight Ball was in a meeting Wednesday night, and unable to comment.
Lane wouldn't speculate on whether other Liberal MHAs are also mulling over voting against the unpopular budget.
"I believe I have done the right thing, but I guess that will be up to the people to judge ultimately."
With files from Peter Cowan